1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

which one is better?

by DizzyW

image.png
DizzyW sorry for the lack of post. I have been very busy with creating an art style that i like. But i thought that i could maybe ask you guys for advice.

So basically these two guys are the same character. The left one has lines and the right one doesnt.
The left one took around 10 minutes and the right one around 17 minutes. I prefer the right one (because of the derp face but that isnt a good reason lol), but that one is kinda hard to do and takes alot of time. So which one do you prefer?
Tags:
  1. Possibilit
    Possibilit
    May 18, 2019 at 5:16 PM
    DizzyW likes this.
  2. DizzyW
    DizzyW
    @Possibilit lmao yea i was already thinking about not drawing that ever again (its fur btw)
    May 18, 2019 at 8:41 AM
  3. Possibilit
    Possibilit
    I dunno about the left one...I don't like the thing on the left ones co- *Demonitized*
    May 18, 2019 at 12:57 AM
    DizzyW likes this.
  4. Altari_owl
    Altari_owl
    I like the lineless more. It seems simple yet professional.
    May 12, 2019
    DizzyW likes this.
  5. Yoshi Star Shine
    Yoshi Star Shine
    I like the guy on the left of your picture.
    I have hope for the future.
    May 11, 2019
    DizzyW likes this.
  6. Mystic Zander
    Mystic Zander
    Left: Ben 10 (2005)

    Right: Ben 10 (reboot)

    The choice is obvious. XD
    May 10, 2019
    DizzyW likes this.
  7. Lana The Umbreon
    Lana The Umbreon
    I like the left one!
    May 6, 2019
    PrincessPika and DizzyW like this.
  8. DizzyW
    DizzyW
    May 4, 2019
  9. RockruffRocks
    RockruffRocks
    May 4, 2019
    Candis and DizzyW like this.
  10. DizzyW
    DizzyW
    @RockruffRocks thanks for the advice lol and btw i like the lineless one more too.
    And yea it might be smart too make the pupils bigger. And you can spam me all you want!
    May 4, 2019
    PrincessPika likes this.
  11. RockruffRocks
    RockruffRocks
    I would make the pupil a bit bigger on the lineless one, but if you like the Tim Burton style eyes, I'm not stopping ya. sorry if i'm spamming your feed i'll stop now
    May 4, 2019
    DizzyW likes this.
  12. RockruffRocks
    RockruffRocks
    ah yes I have the unpopular opinion
    May 4, 2019
    PrincessPika and DizzyW like this.
  13. RockruffRocks
    RockruffRocks
    They're both amazing and way better than I can draw but I'mma have to say i like the lineless style a bit more. Keep up the good work!
    May 4, 2019
    DizzyW likes this.
  14. Brennan kuhl-ream
    Brennan kuhl-ream
    I Like both! you have a great art style!
    May 2, 2019
    DizzyW and glennis75 like this.
  15. DizzyW
    DizzyW
    @glennis75 Thanks for the advice and the compliments! Im trying to post as much as I can, but as you said, life gets in the way. Luckily enough, all these compliments really cheer me up and motivate me! Thanks lol
    May 2, 2019
    glennis75 likes this.
  16. PrincessPika
    PrincessPika
    Kinda hard for me to pick, but I'd say the left one, although there isn't any subtle shading like the right one and, like what glennis and Dreamy said, the lines around the mouth and eyes could be a little thinner.
    May 2, 2019
    DizzyW likes this.
  17. glennis75
    glennis75
    I definitely like the left one better. Something about the one on the right doesn't really appeal to me as much as the left one. I think it's the outline, but yeah. Like @DreamyVictini said, I would make the inner lines thinner, because the outline is what needs to stand out and not necessarily the mouth in this case.

    Great job! I'm happy to see your newest artwork again here on Pokecharms, cuz I know it's been a while and life just gets in the way lol.
    May 2, 2019
    DizzyW and PrincessPika like this.
  18. DizzyW
    DizzyW
    @DreamyVictini thanks for the advice! I could rrly use your advice to improve, so your opinion does mean something. If you need help with the left style or something, just pm me.
    May 2, 2019
    PrincessPika and glennis75 like this.
  19. DreamyVictini
    DreamyVictini
    They both look really nice! And I've been working on an artsyle like the right one but I can't seem to make it work :@ Though, the left one looks slightly better in my opinion. You might want to make the lines thinner for the messy parts (like the mouth), but other than that it's great! my opinion doesn't mean much really I'm just an introvert boy who has an obsession with drawing ;-;
    May 2, 2019
    PrincessPika, glennis75 and DizzyW like this.
  20. DizzyW
    DizzyW
    @LokaMocha haha i needed to try it a couple times too before it looked ok to me. But thanks ^^
    May 2, 2019
    glennis75, PrincessPika and LokaMocha like this.
  21. LokaMocha
    LokaMocha
    Bruh, you make them both look good. I could never do art without lines it never looks right for me.

    I really like them both, frick.
    May 2, 2019
    glennis75, PrincessPika and DizzyW like this.
  22. Luke The Riolu
    Luke The Riolu
    Obviously. . . . The right one !
    (K no srsly left one is better)
    May 2, 2019
    glennis75, PrincessPika and DizzyW like this.