1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Which of AShs starting flying pokemon are the best

Discussion in 'Pokémon Chat' started by Ryan Lisman, Mar 30, 2007.

  1. Ryan Lisman

    Ryan Lisman Guest

    You know how ash always has one major flying pokemon, which one do yo like the most.

    Pidggeto/Pidgeot
    Noctowl
    Tailow/Swellow
    Starly/Mukubird
     
  2. StellarWind Elsydeon

    StellarWind Elsydeon Armblades Ascendant
    Staff Member Administrator

    Mukubird's English name is Staravia, Ryan. Just for you to know.

    The sad part is that all of Ash's birds had the same role and almost the same personality.

    I'll have to go with Pidgeot, for the reason of it being there first, and having had the most personality so far, though his Swellow was also pretty rad.

    But nostalgia wins.
     
  3. Doctor Oak

    Staff Member Overlord

    With the exception of Starly/Staravia, who hasn't really had a chance to do a whole lot yet, I have to say... wow, I love all 3 of 'em.

    I guess, as a personal preference over the actual species, Noctowl would be teh winnar, but overall Pidgeotto/Pidgeot, Noctowl and Swellow have all been pretty much equal in the winsome books.
     
  4. My personal fave is Pidgeotto, but thats just me
     
  5. Linkachu

    Linkachu Hero of Pizza
    Staff Member Administrator

    Hmm... Pidgeot would steal my vote simply for nostalgia reasons, but since we only saw it in that stage for one episode... I'm going to say Swellow. Unlike Noctowl, and even Pidgeotto to an extent, I really took to Taillow/Swellow. It had some really awesome battles, and lots of great moments. Its true that all of Ash's birdies have a similar personality, but I'd still say Swellow... just because.
     
  6. It's between Pidgeot and Swellow. Pidgeot because it was big enough to fly Ash on its back. It would have been cool if Ash took it to the Orange Islands. Swellow because it looks cool and is a good battler. I would have liked to see it use Steel Wing in the Anime.
     
  7. Ryan Lisman

    Ryan Lisman Guest

    I always loved them except for Noctowl, I cried when Pidgeot left. I cant wait to have a starly.


    Thanks for replying
     
  8. For pure nostaligia it has to be Pidggeto.

    I didnt really start paying attention again until swellow and now im growing towards him but my memory of ashes team will always be:

    Bulbasaur,Squirtle,Charizard,Butterfree,Pidggeto and Pickachu.
     
  9. I THINK SELLOW WAS THE STRONGEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!![glow=red,2,300][/glow]
     
  10. StellarWind Elsydeon

    StellarWind Elsydeon Armblades Ascendant
    Staff Member Administrator

    Dude. Read the rules. No all-capsing. x_X
     
  11. Pidgeot was the best, hey... ash lied didn't he say... after the pkmn league he will be back to pick up Pidgeot? He did didnt he?
     
  12. Linkachu

    Linkachu Hero of Pizza
    Staff Member Administrator

    Yeah, he said that in the dub (not sure about the original) and no, he never has come back to get Pidgeot. It's one of those things that drives half of the Pokemon fandom mad - just like the GS Ball :p
     
  13. Even though they are all the same to me I will have to go with Noctowl just because its Shiny.
     
  14. Pidgeot is the best (in my opinion). Is it like the fastest pokemon? But i also like swellow, because its got a lot of determination and power, and also Swellow won a lot of matches for Ash.
    [​IMG]
     
    #15 Phil of Flames, May 8, 2007
    Last edited by a moderator: Jan 30, 2017
  15. Pidgeot for the win!

    Pidgeot was with Ash through the very begining... It left Ash only after it found that flock of Pidgey and Pidgeotto being bullied by a flock of Spearow and a single Fearow. Ash agreed to it staying to watch the flock and said it would come back for it.

    He never did... And I think that stinks...
    considering how loyal Pidgeot was, and how it went through sop much with Ash. Like him losing Butterfree (so it could mate- and wait! Didn't he say he would see it again someday??), Being all those battles...

    Pidgeot for the win...

    All the other birds after that were an attempt to be Pidgeot and it take it's place... Yet they never truly could (for me at least).
     
  16. Pidgeotto/Pidgeot has always been my favorite. It definitely had the most personality and it was with him from the start. Pidgeot owned! I'm still pissed at Ash for leaving it there in the woods :'(
     
  17. i have a bias towards swellow, just because it's really the first one i really trained, and pidgeot just seems to be a pain to me. i like swellow's speed, and its atk. the starly line is good too, but nothing beats that swellow-speed.

    so i vote swellow, and you should prolly make this a poll.
     
  18. Favorite? Well, I'd have to say out of all of them, Pidgeot. Just because it looks better with Ash, and it's appearance looks like Ash's personality (a whole, "you can't beat this" sorta thing). When I heard Ash was going back to Kanto, I thought maybe that the Animé people had remembered what Ash said, so eventually he'd get it back. Oh well. Maybe this coming movie will be it's return? Maybe Dialga went back in time with Ash, showed him what he said, and he got it back. Or Darkrai gives him a horrible dream of Pidgeot being lonely. But, I doubt Ash would care too much, if he were real, but since the sappy Pokemon company owns him, he'll give a crap. Wow, I just typed a lot.
     
    #19 Eevee Lover, May 22, 2007
    Last edited by a moderator: Jul 27, 2014
  19. id never thought about witch was my favorite probally Swellow or Pidgeoto
     
  20. Ash's best flying Pokemon was his Butterfree
    which he caught in the forth episode
    i think he caught Pidgeotto in the third episode which
    technically means that was his starting flying pokemon
    but i still like Butterfree better
     
  21. Ehh, pigeot was pretty awsome but I have to go with swellow. Mainly because he was the fasted out of them all. But pigeot still looks pretty coo. =)
     
  22. Pidgeot

    1. For starters, I've always had a thing for 3-stage Pokemon
    2. Although Noctowl was pretty rare, Ash caught Pidgeot in Viridian Forest as a Pidgeotto, and the odds of that (at least in the 1st gen) are nothing short of miraculous.
    3. Pidgeot displays a personality second only to Swellow, and is much more Valiant.
     
  23. It has to be Pidgeot, seeing as it's the BIGGEST bird Ash has ever had. It also is the most powerfull stat-wise...
     
  24. Maybe they got rid of Pidgeot seeing as how Ash wouldn't need to walk from city to city anymore if he could just fly over using his Pidgeot....
     

  25. ID SAY ALL OF THEM BEACAUSE ALL POKEMON ARE TOUGH~
     
  26. Ugh. All caps. Warned. And please, for the sake of our eyes, don't do it again. >_>
     
  27. Noctowl

    Administratorial Edit: EXPLAIN WHY. This falls under freakishly short posts, ergo spam, ergo, WARNING.
     
  28. I would have to say Pidgeot ^^ Because I love all the originals!!
    Though, Im pretty sure he said "I'll see you around" or something like that to him, not in dub, in dub he said he'd come back O_o..Well maybe he will..Some..Day Lol
    Slightly random but out of all the flyers..Butterfree..Because he was awesome D=
    Though not many people know this, (because they didnt put it in the dub haha) When butterfree's mate they die. So thats why he couldnt see his butterfree again, that kinda clears that up.
    But I love the originals so...Pidgeot!^^ Plus..He was big and strong and..Cute!!^^ No offense but I thought the others looked kinda...Uh..weird..Specially Swellow..o.o
     
  29. Pidgeot of course.By now it should one of Ashy boys most powerful pokemon instead he leaves them with a flock of Pidgey/Pidgeott.Its sad really those freaking birds Pidgeot is protecting should be Pidgeots by now.
     
  30. ash's pidgot
     
  31. Sem

    Sem The Last of the Snowmen
    Former Administrator

    ^ = Freakishly short post. You, sir, get a nice warning. This was right after another person got a warning too. My suggestion is to read the rules and to actually read the thread you're posting in.
     
  32. Pidgeot simply because it looks cool, and apparently it can fly at mach-speed or something. Pidgeot P'Owns. It is too bad that he doesn't get Pidgeot back. That's the first thing I would have done when I got back. Forget the tearful family reunion, I'm going to get my Pidgeot back!
     
  33. Oh, this is an easy one. It's gotta be Noctowl for me. Noctowl...the bird I have currently, Noctowl...the bird I watched last on the Tele, Noctowl...such a cooky little Pokemon -- and that's why I like 'm.

    Oh yeah, and he's an owl. Owl's seem so much different than the other birds, which supports the originality I stand for!
     
  34. I'd say pidgeot because it's big it's fast! :p
     
  35. I'll go with Pigeot. It was a pretty awesome bird, and was with Ash from the (almost) start.
     
  36. Didn't he also said he would go back for primeape? Ohh and about my favorite hmm... Noctowl! plainly because he was shiny.next would be Pegeot.
     
  37. I think its Noctowl

    [​IMG]
     
  38. I would have to say swellow, its got lots of personality and a great battler.
     

Share This Page