Well, I know this is alittle late to the party, but I don't have the attention span to do this next Halloween. So Happy 7-day-post-Halloween Topic! 
Okay, now we can list scenes from games that have either jumped-scared, disturbed, or just plane mindf*cked us. Only rules I got is that it's from a non-horror or horror-game, one scene per franchise (or else this topic would be flooded with Silent Hill) and it has to be disturbing, not exactly scary. Let's Begin.
5.- The Dentist (Bioshock)
Oh~ some of you are cringing right now at the thought of this guy. To elaborate, you enter a room for a dentist's office. As we all know, Rapture isn't exactly in top shape, so the door is blocked, and there are dead bodies everywhere. When you find the alternate way to get into the room, you find a dead body on a dentist's chair. Then the room fills with gas and the body disappears. You don't pay anymind to it until you get the plasmid on the wall. Then...you find the dentist staring you down RIGHT FREAKIN BEHIND YOU. O.O
4.- Scarecrow's 3rd Mirage (Batman: Arkham Asylum)
Naturally, most of this game has pretty disturbing parts, but the last of Scarecrows mirage take the cake. I don't want to spoil it, but let's just say you it will make you think back to a level of insanity close to Eternal Darkness...speaking of which...
3.- Bathtub Scene/Memory Card Currupted scene (Eternal Darkness)
This game was DESIGNED to f*ck with your brain, which is why it is so hard to decide on one scene, so I'll pick two.
Well, the Bathtub scene starts off with you entering a bathroom hunkey-dorey...until a dead, skin-less body with cuts all over it instantaniously pops up in the bathtub. Which then overflows with blood. Thing is, you do not see it coming, which made me nearly crap myself first time I played. Then the memory card scene. This didn't really disturb me, as much as give me a heart attack. The game breaks the fourth wall, by having a blue screen come up and say your memory card data was currupted and erased of all your games. Cue blood-curdling "NOOOOOOO!!"
2.- Pyramid Head Encounter (Silent Hill)
Do I even nedd to say anything about this? IT'S F*CKIN' PYRAMID HEAD! You alwys encounter him when You have low ammunition, so you want to savor every bullet you have. Plus he rapes dolls...
1.- Giygas Battle (Earthbound)
Aw, how can a kid's game, never-the-less a Nintendo game, ever possibly be disturbing? Becuase most gamers still get goosebumps hearing Giygas's dailog, music, and the the idea behind his creation (the director of the game once walked into the rape scene of a movie when he was a kid, which he created Giygas based on the expierence).
Okay, now we can list scenes from games that have either jumped-scared, disturbed, or just plane mindf*cked us. Only rules I got is that it's from a non-horror or horror-game, one scene per franchise (or else this topic would be flooded with Silent Hill) and it has to be disturbing, not exactly scary. Let's Begin.5.- The Dentist (Bioshock)
Oh~ some of you are cringing right now at the thought of this guy. To elaborate, you enter a room for a dentist's office. As we all know, Rapture isn't exactly in top shape, so the door is blocked, and there are dead bodies everywhere. When you find the alternate way to get into the room, you find a dead body on a dentist's chair. Then the room fills with gas and the body disappears. You don't pay anymind to it until you get the plasmid on the wall. Then...you find the dentist staring you down RIGHT FREAKIN BEHIND YOU. O.O
4.- Scarecrow's 3rd Mirage (Batman: Arkham Asylum)
Naturally, most of this game has pretty disturbing parts, but the last of Scarecrows mirage take the cake. I don't want to spoil it, but let's just say you it will make you think back to a level of insanity close to Eternal Darkness...speaking of which...
3.- Bathtub Scene/Memory Card Currupted scene (Eternal Darkness)
This game was DESIGNED to f*ck with your brain, which is why it is so hard to decide on one scene, so I'll pick two.
Well, the Bathtub scene starts off with you entering a bathroom hunkey-dorey...until a dead, skin-less body with cuts all over it instantaniously pops up in the bathtub. Which then overflows with blood. Thing is, you do not see it coming, which made me nearly crap myself first time I played. Then the memory card scene. This didn't really disturb me, as much as give me a heart attack. The game breaks the fourth wall, by having a blue screen come up and say your memory card data was currupted and erased of all your games. Cue blood-curdling "NOOOOOOO!!"2.- Pyramid Head Encounter (Silent Hill)
Do I even nedd to say anything about this? IT'S F*CKIN' PYRAMID HEAD! You alwys encounter him when You have low ammunition, so you want to savor every bullet you have. Plus he rapes dolls...
1.- Giygas Battle (Earthbound)
Aw, how can a kid's game, never-the-less a Nintendo game, ever possibly be disturbing? Becuase most gamers still get goosebumps hearing Giygas's dailog, music, and the the idea behind his creation (the director of the game once walked into the rape scene of a movie when he was a kid, which he created Giygas based on the expierence).
