Mafia 1: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Six deaths? Who even of?! Who has the mafia been offing without anyone noticing?!

Also some really should wash up that blood, it's unsightly.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

I think the fact that El didn't cast blame is pretty suspicious |D

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Figures that Sem would be the first to cast suspicion on others. Then again, just look at Sem...he lies to you even when admitting he's lying. He's some kind of super lying machine.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

You're so smart, Red =)

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

I agree with Red about Sem, but he's suspicious too. He could be using his knowledge of Sem against us to throw us off the trail! Or he could know something about Sem that we don't... Personally I don't trust anyone.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Tangrow's the most suspicious if you ask me, that diabetes-inducing personality is clearly hiding something (though it may just be his inner emo/homocidal maniac)

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Totally agree with what El said. Tan is the opposite of the Mafia characteristics, so we'd expect someone else; the perfect disguise.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

I concur

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

That is very true. Tan has that unimposing personality that you wouldn't suspect killing you. :x But would we be willing to lynch somebody who is so unimposing?

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Well we all seem to be going towards El's suggestion, but what if that's his plan? He may just want to off another innocent before he kills in the night.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

El's too fabulous to kill someone himself.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Dwayna's a bit quick to cast the blame on anyone who isn't herself. Is she naturally suspicious of everyone, or does she have something to hide?

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Well that's why there is more than one mafia member. Plus, just look at his first post. He was pretty quick to want the blood (evidence) taken away. Plus, he decided to dictate chat.

And Sho's looking pretty suspicious in protecting El.

Edit: Very true, El. She has been very suspicious of you for attacking Tan.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Well of course nobody's going to want to cast the blame on themselves, now are they? As far as we know, we can only trust ourselves. Anyone could be the culprit. Including Tan.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Aye Red - Sho's quick defence for El does arouse suspicion. He may be covering for El for other reasons, however...

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Or, you know, Sho was just commenting on El's fabulousity and you're all reading too much into things |D If we allow any little thing to grab our attention then we will destroy ourselves and the mafia will win. We need to be smart about this people.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

But this early in the game we pretty much have to grab at anything. Or just all decide who we should kill for the fun of it. XD Unless we can be nice people and spare folks. Which I'm not sure if we could. :x

So yeah, if we have to kill somebody without anything to show people's motives then we have to grasp at something. I mean, I know I don't want the mafia killing me or the town's folk. Do you, Sem? >:T (Disregard the fact that you feed on our sorrow and deaths for a moment. :x)

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

I'd say we focus on someone who hasn't yet said anything, which is equally as suspicious as anything anyone has said here.

Tan would enjoy the idea of anyone of us dying, and we all know his unimposing demeanor is simply a facade. Even if he isn't mafia, he would quickly save his own hide and watch one of us die instead. He's a danger either way. I say we off him.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Ha. Tan is indeed suspicious, as previously stated. Then again, you already have pre-existing motives against Tan, Sem. Do you not? Emo vs Rainbows, Dark vs Light, Sem vs Tan?!

But yes, I agree that there is probably a better chance that somebody who hasn't spoken up yet is a member of the mafia than one that has. (What with simple math and all. ) Now we also have to ask, would a person who is not a regular around here be a member of the mafia or detective or doctor? That is certainly something interesting to wonder about.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

I thought it was particularly suspicious that people started ganging up on Tangrow just because he would be the person we least suspect. However, I do not disagree with the notion that Tangrow could be involved.

The little things could end up being important... Which leads me to suspect that Sem is trying to throw us off the trail. However, throwing around accusations doesn't seem to be helping anyone. Sem does present a compelling case... We do need to think smart, lest we destroy ourselves.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

I'm no more suspicious than you, miss Dway, trying to defend anyone who has blame cast on them ;-D

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

She's very protective. Possibly the Doctor?

But obviously that is not who we are looking for. I say that we give Tan the chance to defend himself before tying the noose. Then after he has spoken, we can go ahead with it. XP

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

i agree with yoshi's first assumption about tangrow

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

That is true, dear Sem, but I would rather not put all of our stones into one basket. Unfortunately, we need to decide one way or the other who to kill... even if it's me. I'm just trying to put some speculation on the matter because we don't know all the facts. Anyone could be part of the mafia... but the same can go for townsfolk, the Doctor and the Detective.

I agree with Red that we should let Tan speak for himself, but I wont cast my gaze away from anyone. Previous loyalties are as good as dead in this situation.

Also, pyro is now under suspect as well as El. They could be working together.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

I agreed with El as well, in fact El was the first to cast suspicion on Tan. Am I also in league with El? ;o

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

truly, anyone could be it and i have suspicions about dwayna seeing as she has accused people for stating their opinions also who is this El

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

El = Yoshimitsu

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Well, you could be. You were one of the three to agree to the idea right away. Also Sho seems to have an affinity with El... you could all be working together.

I also find it somewhat suspicious that Red was the first to mention that there could be multiple mafia members. Also, why is he trying to pinpoint the Doctor, who is an essential asset to us?

I accuse anyone who is eager to accuse others, pyro. But we are all eager to accuse, including you.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

thanks sem and im just looking at facts to save our boots from killin the wrong one

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Now I do believe casting the blames left and right like this is exactly what the Mafia would want, and seeing as it's very difficult to get a proper suspicion the first day of the first round, there's very little evidence over who is the culprit that was, in fact, chosen by the host, and has nothing to do with personality, (at least, from what we know) I'm still thinking over who to vote for.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

'Facts' are fickle when anyone could be making an elaborate deception, pyro. We need to keep in mind that the mafia could be any of the suspicious townsfolk.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

that is true dwayna

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

In response to this, the rules state that there are multiple members. We just don't know how many exactly. For all we know half the people playing could be mafia.

Personally I say that, rather than needlessly casting suspicion we all agree on who to eliminate. Or possibly even nominate people...to be lynched. >> I have to agree with RMA when he said that us all arguing and jumping down eachother's throats just helps the mafia. We have to be sensible about things.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Right... remind me to read things thoroughly in the future. @-@

You do have a good point though, Red. Since Tangrow seems to be the person most people are agreeing on then he might not have much of a chance. If he turns out to be innocent, however, I do think we should turn our eyes to those so willing to accuse him in the first place.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

But he has as good a chance as being a mafia member as anybody. You included, there Dway.

But for the time being, I will stand united with my fellow towns folk and cast my current suspicion on Tan. (I fear his fate may be sealed before he gets the chance to defend himself, but I guess that's just how things go sometimes. :T)

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

I vote for tan

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Sem seems quick to admonish our views on people, clearly asking us to look not-deep-enough. Whether he's being genuine about this or is trying to cover for himself is, as of yet, unclear. More evidence must be gained.

I wouldn't be wary of those who haven't posted yet - there's every chance they're too held up at the moment. Charms traffic can be a bitch, after all.

I am curious about pyroblade55, though. He seems to be able to back up his statements with 'facts', or rather with obvious truths. How key a player is he, or is he acting on instinct?

It'd be hasty to jump to conclusions right now, since we know barely anything about anyone.

</drunken posting>

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

El makes some good points... and frankly I agree that pyro does seem suspect for jumping on me so readily. I also agree with him that others who haven't posted yet could be of suspect.

However, that doesn't misplace my suspicion of El, either. He was the first to start our at present Tangrow bandwagon. Anyone is innocent until proven guilty, in my opinion, and we won't really know until after someone dies.

 

Re: Day One (June 14th-16th): Enter the Lion's Den

Oh no, dear Dwayna. We're all guilty until proven innocent. And right now to be proven innocent you also have to die =)